Skip to main content

Employment Law Versus Human Rights Law - The Saga Of CCTV Cameras


It comes as no surprise to many that the UK has more CCTV cameras per person than anywhere else in the world; leading human rights lawyers to warn that their almost constant use in our everyday lives raises data protection and wider privacy concerns, since they can be used in an intrusive way.

But what are the limits? At the workplace, employers are permitted to monitor workers in so far as it is necessary and proportionate to the management's reasons. CCTV monitoring is often undertaken for security reasons and is thus widely viewed as reasonable. It follows that employees naturally inspire reassurance from their respective employers that they are using CCTV responsibly.

The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) published its first CCTV Data Protection Code of Practice in 2000 to help CCTV operators comply with the Data Protection Act 1998 (DPA) and follow good practice.

The Code of Practice: Monitoring at Work gives guidance on how to avoid employees calling in the lawyers over breaching the provisions of the DPA. The Code provides that before such monitoring is introduced, an impact assessment must be carried out to determine what (if any) monitoring is justified by the benefits of that monitoring. Under the DPA, any CCTV monitoring must normally be open and backed by fulfilling reasons.

The assessment should consider targeting the monitoring only at the areas of particular risk, confining it to areas where people's expectations of privacy would be low, using video and audio monitoring separately - cases where the use of both to be justified becomes rare. Its operation should only be where deemed necessary rather than continuous - although continuous monitoring may be justified where security is at risk. Finally, whether comparable benefits can be obtained by less intrusive methods and what adverse impact it may have on workers.

In making the assessment it is advisable for the employer to consult trade unions/employee representatives.

If the monitoring is introduced to enforce certain rules and standards, the employer must ensure that the workers are aware of and understand them.
According to one employment lawyer, the use of CCTV to monitor the actions of employees has potential implications in respect of the Data Protection Act and the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA). If the surveillance is excessive, the implications may vary depending on whether the employer is a public or private body or individual.

If the employer is a private organisation or company, then direct reliance on HRA is not possible. Nevertheless, all contracts of employment contain an implied term that employers will not - without reasonable and proper cause - conduct themselves in a manner likely to destroy or seriously damage the relationship of trust between themselves and employees. Yet, it is doubtful that CCTV cameras in obvious places in the workplace would violate this implied term.

On the other hand, an employer in a public body has an obligation to respect workers right to private life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (as enacted by HRA). However, this right is a qualified right which means that it may be interfered with for a legitimate purpose in accordance with law and is necessary in the interests of national security, public safety or the economic well-being of the country for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others. The interference must be proportionate in achieving its aim. An example of disproportionate use may arguably be where cameras are put in toilets or changing rooms.

Ultimately, it should be borne in mind that despite the points outlined there is very little scope to impede employers making recordings. Placement and retention of footage must be in accordance with regulations under DPA. As this is a relatively recent development in the law, there are very few decided cases (the DPA does not apply to individuals' private or household purposes).

Assistance for employees comes from either expressing direct concerns to the employer which is the easiest way to resolve the situation or from a union if the worker is a member.

Any personal data collected must be stored securely. Also, regard should be had to the fact that anyone who is captured on CCTV will have a right of access to that footage under the DPA.


About the author :
Adam Singleton

Comments

This is a very wonderful post . thanks for sharing this post information. it is a very nice blog information.
CCTV installation in Mumbai
Security Systems are as important as Door Lock now a days.Sm info tech working as CCTV Camera Service Provider In Guwahati also serves bio-metric installation. fire alarm installation etc.
Abeera Ltd Professional CCTV Installation Services Provider in London. We offer cost-effective installations & maintenance of CCTV, Intruder Alarm, Gate Automation, Door Entry System and Access Control Systems in Croydon, London.

Popular posts from this blog

CCTV Camera Systems - IP Vs Analog

CCTV Camera have come a long way since being first presented into the industry in the late 1950's. There are all kinds of CCTV Security Camera now such as dome Security Camera, topic Security Camera, IR Security Camera that can see in the dark and even tiny little pen Security Camera like the Wayne Connection. The wireless protection electronic camera industry has become one of the quickest growing sectors these days since Sept Eleventh. Analogue and IP Security Camera are the two kinds of CCTV Security Camera available currently in the marketplace. And while though analog CCTV Security Camera are still the most widely used kind, the functions and versatility that customers & businesses can gain by using IP CCTV techniques compared to analog are tremendous. Some functions include, Security Camera that run on energy over Ethernet (POE). What this implies is that the electronic camera can be powered and transfer movie nourish all with one Cat5 wire, rather than running a en

How to choose best Surveillance CCTV Camera?

How to choose best Surveillance CCTV Camera? CCTV cameras have evolved substantially in the last decade. But in all fairness, these are not a part and parcel in everyone’s life. So looking through the newest of CCTV technologies, features and types of CCTV security cameras can be intimidating. Also, asking for help from a marketing consultant could be just a waste of time. They usually throw in the most polished words to make buying CCTVs all the more difficult. So before you choose the best CCTV camera for your home or business, you need to have a brief idea on what to look for. 1. Does it come with an inbuilt SD card slot or does it depend on a separate internal storage on DVR? With the advancement of CCTV technology, today many of the CCTV cameras are CCTV systems by themselves. They come with a micro SD card slot in them. Users can insert memory cards of various capacities, 32GB, 64GB, or 128GB for recording. Many of modern CCTV cameras sold in India are upgradeable up

A Look Within CCTV Cameras

The CCTV Camera has certainly been able to produce a lot of advertising for itself during the modern times. Many latest styles are starting when it comes to spy and undercover devices. A lot of individuals have actually taken plenty of interest in these CCTV digital cams which are often described as the camera in a lighting style. These CCTV digital cams can be quickly attached onto any lighting style plug because the inside of the CCTV camera is a very innovative low-light grayscale camera. CCTV Camera Facts: - The video signal of the CCTV camera is protected and fed immediately to a 110-volt energy line - Each and every CCTV camera also has a associate decoder that can be connected to even a common home owners TV set - Uses conventional movie result using line-level RCA type cables - Designed in infra-red system for seeing pictures clearly even in complete night and up to a highest possible of 30 feet 1. Awesome Durability The CCTV camera has already been